Murder of Elizabeth Bainbridge

Accused murderer of Elizabeth Bainbridge

Elizabeth Bainbridge was born at Bradfleld St Clare. When she was twenty she married the butler in the house in which she was employed as a servant. The marriage was not a success. Her husband was a bully and wife-beater and within a year of the marriage Elizabeth's father, having heard of his daughter's ill-treatment, took her and her baby daughter to live with him at Lawshall.

Also living in Lawshall was good-looking young labourer. George Carnt. Quiet and respected, at twenty-three he had fallen desperately in love with Elizabeth, who was seven years older. She returned this love, realising at the same time the hopelessness of their position.

One January evening in 1851 the customers of “The Harrow” public house in Lawshall were startled when George Carnt staggered in, covered with mud, wet and shaking. He refused to make any explanation and pleaded to be left alone, whispering “The Devil has got me; the halter is for my neck." But later that night, by the light of lanthorns, a search party found the body of Betsy Bainbridge in a pond.

Carnt was tried the Suffolk Assizes for her murder. At the trial the defence counsel produced the improbable story that Carnt had had epileptic fit and had fallen upon his sweetheart, accidentally knocking her into the pond and drowning her. It wasn’t until after the death sentence that Carnt broke his silence and told the pitiful circumstances of two young people driven desperate by their hopeless love. He told how they had walked through the fields and exchanged love tokens—he had given her his watch and she had given him her wedding ring. Suddenly, overcome with unhappiness, Elizabeth took Carnt's pocket knife, saying she would kill herself, George took the knife from her, though she begged him to kill her. He refused, but her own unhappiness was transmitted to him. He said. "No, if you mean to kill yourself, we will both do it together: we will both drown ourselves.’’

He dragged her, struggling and screaming, to the pond and held her beneath the green water. When he threw himself into the pond the instinct of self-preservation was too strong, and he returned, dazed and demented, to Lawshall.

An application for a reprieve was made on the grounds that the crime was unpremeditated and unconcealed afterwards. The application was rejected.

Between 4.000 and 5.000 people gathered during that Easter holiday around the Bury St Edmunds gaol. The contemporary report continues; "The behaviour of the people was on the whole decorous, except for some occasional levities during the time of suspense. Shortly after nine o'clock the death-bell was heard sounding mournfully through the air and the fatal procession began to emerge from the condemned cell, the operation of pinioning was very quickly performed. At this moment much of the strength of nerve which had distinguished the culprit both before and after condemnation seemed to fail him; his face turned pale and his whole frame was violently agitated. 

In about five minutes afterwards he was conducted to the scaffold, exclaiming low but audible accents, ‘Lord! have mercy upon my soul.’ The rope was adjusted to a staple fixed in the beam, and in less than a minute the cap was drawn over his face, and the executioner retired. “At the appointed signal, the closing of the chaplain’s book, the bolt was drawn, and without a struggle the unhappy man was dismissed into eternity amidst the breathless silence of the spectators. His death was instantaneous, the slight convulsive motion of his body a few seconds after the drop had fallen being after life had ceased to exist,’ So ended the pathetic little love story of George Carnt and Elizabeth Bambndge.